Skip to main content

Yagami Hayate and... Yagami Light?

8 replies [Last post]
Sansker's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/01/2011
Posts: 1003

I know what you are thinking: “WTF?!” but I’m being death serious here. As a fan of both Maho Shojo Lyrical Nanoha and Death Note I always wonder the possibility of these two characters being related. Of course the most common assumption is that they happen to have identical lasts names but aside that are two complete different characters and they will never share anything else. Well… I disagree with that. Actually I believe that, somehow, Hayate is a relative of Light and they give us clues about it all the time. So I will point out the similitude between them and you are welcome to put your own.

1 – Their last names. This is so obvious it have to be a lie. They are both Yagami and, don’t you think is a little suspicious that Hayate’s parents are dead? Consider how many people die thanks to the Death Note I have to say there is a little possibility here. Also the fact that Sochiro Yagami, Light’s father, spends so much time out open the possibility of an adventure.

2 – Their hair.
They both happen to have similar hair color and hair style. That, in much anime, make it to be either clones or siblings so… well you see my point.

3 – The books. Both of them get powerful weapons that happen to look like two innocents books… ok a note and a book but they both have covers and pages that can be used with lethal proposes.

4 – Their servants. Ignoring the fact that Hayate considers the Wolkenritter as part of her family; both she and Light have under their command some non-human creatures. Hayate the gardians ans Light his Shinigami.

5 – Their uniforms. If you see Light’s high school uniform looks like Hayate’s, just hers is a little lighter in color.

Also both of them get chosen by the laws of destiny and casualty to wheel their power and both of them use it to create a better world. What did you think?

depression76's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/04/2010
Posts: 528

Ah, an old theory.

Honestly, Light would be an awesome male counterpart for Hayate, sans the psychotic tendencies of course.

ForceSix's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/12/2012
Posts: 98

That's a scary thought...

Who would in a fight? Nanoha or Saber? Archer or Signum?

Sansker's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/01/2011
Posts: 1003

More than just a scary thought. If we take the idea as true… the possibilities are just endless. Now just image the amout of damage a Death Note will do in the MSLN universe. Also the killing that someone like Light will do. He is not a stupid crazy doctor but rather a far intelligent confident person. Is sinister, smart, cold, etc… from an intelligence perspective I believe none on the MSLN could keep up a mind like Light Yagami. And if you think right… what is Hayate ends getting the Death Note?!

My hope is that Subaru and her sisters get one… they are so idiot that the first thing they do with it will be writing on the note: “This note is property of…”

LOLIKNOW's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/26/2011
Posts: 276

Haha, a death note in MSLN?

Subaru or Teana would mistaken it for a diary and everyone would die. The End.

Or

Vita would get her hands on it and everyone would still die. Fin.

Philosophical juggernaut, disabled Bruce Lee

Android_Chaos's picture
Offline
Joined: 07/31/2010
Posts: 392

TV Tropes had that theory on Nanoha's Wild Mass Guessing section.

Sansker's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/01/2011
Posts: 1003

The worse part if that in case these two Yagamis here were siblings then Hayate has the evil Kira genes. Also the plot line of Betrayers will make a lot more of sense, because the introduction of Kira and the Death Note bring the idea of the grey area of morality, were kind of make sense that good people do “bad” things in order to preserve the society.

Also I read some stuff on TV Tropes but I never watch this idea. The idea came to me in other forum I use to comment. And so I decided to say it to you. Still make me wonder: what could happen is the character get to know each other?

Jokulhaup's picture
Offline
Joined: 04/10/2010
Posts: 417

The doujin Lyrical Death Note is kind of a crossover between DN and MSLN when Fate finds the Death Note and proceeds to kill everyone between herself and Nanoha. :D

Check out my stories! Tell me what you think!
Photoshoot
Just Like Fate
Endymion

Sansker's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/01/2011
Posts: 1003

Yes, but is a comedy doujin. The funny part is that is not that far from Death Note original idea. The first story with the Death Note was a lot less obscure than the anime. I mean in that story the dead can bring back to life by either erase the name of the note or destroying the page where the mane are written. In the doujin they have and Death Eraser or something like that.