It's been quite a while since I wrote fanfiction of any kind, but I've gotten a bit of a muse back.
The Nanoha story ideas I'm considering/working on:
- a oneshot about Nanoha dying in the 0068 incident, and Fate refusing to accept that reality; this story I've started writing
- a Super Robot Wars-esque story combining several Mahou Shoujo series into one world, primarily Nanoha, Madoka Magica, and Sailor Moon
- a Nanoha x Dragonball crossover that meshes the two worlds into one around the time of Nanoha A's and the Saiyan Saga; I particularly want to do this one
- a story where Due survives StrikerS and is still at large
- a story where Yuuno gets to be the main character for once, maybe about his archaeological adventures
I do like the crossovers idea, wrote a couple myself, but mostly depends what you aim for. I dare say the Super Robot stuff or the Dragon Ball crossover sound best.
"I do like the crossovers idea, wrote a couple myself, but mostly depends what you aim for. I dare say the Super Robot stuff or the Dragon Ball crossover sound best."
I also like crossover too. It seem nowadays so fond of crossovers, here's some example from games; "For Honor", "Pirates vs Knights vs Vikings", "Megaman Issues Comics" and etc.
I thought of this crossover idea of Irregular magic high school with Nanoha universe. Especially "Shiba Tatsuya" taught engineeres of TSAB of being more creative & enhancing in creating devices, and teach TSAB mages of using cast jamming; <Also included pseudo cast jamming that different waves interact with each other will neutralize their effects>, "Think like "+" combine with "-" then the result is neutral, thus no damage.", that also include using real combat experiences to teach mages and newcomers.
Shiba Tatsuya is Best CAD engineer for creating and inventing new theories and devices for his universe. So I imaging how will TSAB turn into when Shiba Tatsuya suddenly entered into Nanoha Verse.
Just think like Drifters suddenly entered into mysterious world before their death in their own real world. "Drifters Manga".
"I do like the crossovers idea, wrote a couple myself, but mostly depends what you aim for. I dare say the Super Robot stuff or the Dragon Ball crossover sound best."
.
I will presume you are quoting me here. There is a button for that, on the right corner of the message, press it and you can make quotes appear a bit more properly
If Tatsuya got involve he would just single handily cure cancer, solve all issues with the technology, defeat the bad guys by staring at them and act all snub about it. So I do not recommend. Being serious I do like the one with time travel more than the others but I like that type of ideas. However it would live or die depending on who is the one send back
I see, not a bad idea but sometimes people don't like OCs taking over the role from the cast of the show. Not saying is a bad idea but it could easily make them too important and most of the time people go to fanfics to read adventures of the people from the show, not the authors original creations. The idea is quite good but I may recomend you reconsider using Vivio or Einhard instead of an OC. However if you feel the latter is the better choice then go right ahead
As long as you can keep the large cast and settings balance, then I say is a good way of going about it.
Still you are having plenty to work with already so try to keep some points of atention so people don't get distracted. An issue here could be that since you have so many, the main character isn't clear and that can somtimes hurt a story, since is harder to figure out who should we care about and why
Sounds about right, but keep in mind one thing I always remember when I do crossovers: “If Frodo and Sam, in the Lord of the Rings, had manage to get lightsabers then Sauron would get himself a Death Star”
Meaning that if you are going to enhance the good guys with this combination, the bad guys must also be consider. Plus keep in mind that in Dragon Ball ki isn’t the same as magic, we do see magicians and other users of spells in that world but they stablish that the power the magicians wield is not ki base. So there is that to keep in mind as well
I know what you mean. I once read a crossover between Nanoha and Sailor Moon. Not a bad concept but too heavily in favor of Nanoha at the cost of the Sailor Moon lore and characters. Not what I call a good idea.
Back to yours, I think you have the right path so just go ahead.
To be fair, Hayate was never that well integrated in to the mix in the original show. But I can see your point.
Also yes, I think that was the one. I just didn't like how preachy and murder happy it went, one shooting Sailor Moon villains.
All of them sound like worthy ideas. I just warn against the Phastom Menace as a quality example. Plus the backstory of Presea and Graham seems rather unnecesary, both play influential roles with Fate and Hayate but their legacies lives on them.
The idea with Yuuno would work I feel for a short story. Really not much there to explore unless looking for some world building. Also I think this was an accident but I can be wrong.
This one I would not know. Not a Yuuno fan but if it works then go ahead.
Anything is better than Force. But yours sounds quite curious
The not holy, not roman and not empire, Holy Roman Empire. But is a fair way to see it a loose confederations of unique states under one banner that doesn't really do much. Explains its fall in to the Saint Kaiser Unification Wars.
Sounds a good foundation, but don't get too lost on the details. I do say seems possible base on the little lore we have on Belka from the show.
Not really, the Wolkenritter had lost their memories about their past lifes, only fragmented images remain. So they not having a connection with these group sounds fine. Heck they ignore the Saint Church and they are the closes Belkan-like people they have at hand
The Super Magic Wars idea I had written up is as such: in the Vivid time period, a great catastrophe brings Earth, Mid-childa and other worlds to ruin; an invincible force that the characters find impossible to overcome. The only way to prevent this future is to go back in time to stop it from ever happening, yet through a series of tragic events the only one who can go back is a weak mage. Her task is to find Nanoha and the other magic-users of the past(those from Madoka, Sailor Moon and possibly other series) in order to stop the foe that destroys the world before it becomes impossibly strong.
The NanohaxDBZ one would be a pretty straightforward fusion of the two worlds. Things like Nanoha being involved in the battle with the Saiyans, some of the Z-fighters getting involved in the Book of Darkness incident, new friendships arising, and both series' character developing in new ways due to their exposure to elements from the other series.